« Another warrior returns | Main | More on the Salem-Keizer School District »

March 25, 2005


Update on Salem-Keizer School District

Two weeks ago, Shea Riecke took a picture of her active duty USMC brother, Cpl Bill Riecke who graduated from McKay high school, to her high school social studies classroom to share with other students.

In order to display it, the school district told her that it would have to be altered to remove the gun. We printed Connie's letter to the school district earlier and asked you to comment. Many of you did and the story hit the city newspaper today in an editorial by Carol McAlice Currie:

Unless they want to risk violating the school-district's zero-tolerance for weapons policy, Salem-Keizer student marksmen cannot have a pistol embroidered on their letterman jackets. Teen hunters are not allowed to wear silk-screened T-shirt images of themselves standing with rifles and bagged bulls.

And now, a high-school freshman who wants to hang a picture of her brother serving in the military is finding similar prohibitions because the image features a fully automatic rifle and a machine gun.

Last week, Shea Riecke, a freshman at McKay High School, tried to take a snapshot of her brother, Cpl. Bill Riecke, a Marine currently stationed in Twenty-nine Palms, Calif., to her social studies class.

She wanted to display the picture with those of other McKay grads' career choices. Riecke's teacher, Rick Costa, encourages the exhibits.

But Riecke's photo created a little controversy. Actually, it kicked up a sandstorm of grief for the family and school-district officials because of the photo's content. It pictures the Marine hefting a big gun while decked in military desert camies (camouflage). It was taken while he was stationed in Iraq; he will be redeployed there this summer.

The image of Shea's brother does not necessarily convey military service, said Simona Boucek, Salem-Keizer's communications coordinator, and the automatic weapons are the most prominent feature in the photo. The soldiers are pictured casually in a nondescript room.

School officials denied the photo on the grounds the guns in the picture violated district policy. Riecke's mother, Connie Riecke, appealed to district officials including Superintendent Kay Baker. Connie Riecke said she has not heard back from the district but was told that it probably could be displayed if she consented to having the weapons removed, via computer, from the photograph. Riecke said her son insists that it run as it is or not at all. She agrees with him.

"I don't think our school policies are meant to rewrite history. It doesn't make any sense to me," Connie Riecke said. "Are they going to go through every textbook and take out pictures of the Civil War that have soldiers carrying guns? Are they going to go through the library and take out all the Time magazines that feature soldiers with guns? I don't think so."

Connie Riecke said she understands the district's policy but thinks it should make an exception in this case.

"I want educators to be truthful," Riecke said. "This is a career choice, and children need to know that this is an important but dangerous job."

She believes that if the district allows military officers to recruit in high schools, it shouldn't conceal realistic images like the one of her son.

"It's a difficult issue for the district," Boucek said. "We'd be happy to honor her son and his service to our country, but it has to be a photo that's more appropriate for the classroom."

Boucek said an official portrait in dress uniform would work.

"We understand the girl's concerns, but our policy prohibits any display of weapons. This photo just isn't right for a classroom," Boucek said.

The district's caution is understandable, especially when earlier this week, a 16-year-old Minnesota student went on a shooting rampage at his high school, killing five students, a teacher and a security guard. He also killed his grandfather and the grandfather's companion before the attack at the high school, where he later killed himself.

This is a tough choice.

I don't believe that the minds of our high-school students are so malleable that they can be changed by the presence of a photograph, and sanitizing frightens me when government does it, so I wince if schools are doing the same.

But how do we know where to draw the line in this hot desert sand

For these Marines, that line was drawn in Iraq where they have spent months at war with insurgents bent on crushing the birth of democracy. It takes weapons to do that. Cpl Riecke and the other two Marines in the picture are infantry Marines, who served in one of the most dangerous regions of Iraq, and they take their weapons with them everywhere. On some bases, weapons can be secured when they are within the perimeters. Not in Husaybah. My son (1/7 Marines who replaced 3/7 when they came home last year) was shot at more times than he could count by snipers and mortered by insurgents on a regular basis. When I told him this story, he said that it's hard for people back here to understand that the weapon becomes an extension of the Marine. It's necessary. They understand that.

Unfortunately, people like Superintendent Kay Baker and Communications Coordinator Simona Boucek do not. They live in Oregon, a far reach from any battlefield. Their ability to drive through town without fear of being blown up by an IED, their freedom to walk down the street without worry of being taken out by a mortar or bullet, has been guaranteed by the blood, sweat, lives, and bullets expended by Marines and other troops for hundreds of years.

Educators at this school district take pride in instilling critical thinking skills in its students. If only that same standard were applied to educators.

The hot potato has evidently been tossed to Boucek. Here is her e-mail address: BOUCEK_SIMONA@salkeiz.k12.or.us

And, if you'd like to point out the obvious distinctions between a troubled young teen in Minnesota who shot up a school, and our armed forces who are protecting the innocent in Iraq, feel free to drop a note to the Salem Statesman-Journal expressing your opinion of this situation, here's a contact: ccurrie@statesmanjournal.com


Posted by Deb at March 25, 2005 09:42 AM

Comments