July 18, 2004
Was OIF a legitimate war?
There's been much debate in countries around the world, especially the U.S. and Great Britain. It's a healthy debate; that's what free people living in democracies do. But, what do the newly freed Iraqis think? Omar provides us with translated viewpoints from the BBC Arabic discussion forum:
"The report of Lord Butler reflects the respect for the laws in a country that has no written constitution. From my point ov view I think that the report is incomplete because it didnít mention a (thank you) to Mr. Blair and Mr. Bush for doing this honorable job which is toppling the pervert dictator and crushing the iron security grip for the worst tyrant in the world. The soldiers who died in Iraq gave their lives as tributes for freedom. Thanks to all the soldiers who risked and lost their lives for the sake of othersí freedom." Mohammed Abdul Jabbar-Baghdad.
"The world is busy discussing the points that shouldíve forbidden the war. Iraqis were dying and no one bothered himself to ask about the "legal position" when Saddam was murdering Iraqis in thousands. This issue has many aspects: first of all itís a proof for the democracy of the west that doesnít allow to rush into wars without reasonable excuses, unlike the Arab regimes that goes into a war just because the leader wants to be the "hero of the Arab Nation". Another point is that we, in Iraq believe that Saddam and his co-butchers were the real WMDs. Iraqis are benefitting from the mistakes of the British intelligence, so we thank them for this mistake!"
"I think that Bush and Blair are the heroes of democracy, humanity and the war on terror and state terror. Itís possible that some intelligence reports were exaggerated but the result at the end is in the interest of the Iraqi people. Those two men deserve all appreciation and respect. I can say that there was some exaggeration in the criticism also because Saddam did use chemical weapons against us and against Iran."
"Who said there are no WMDs in Iraq? The most dangerous WMD exists and the American troops captured it. Itís the weapon that exterminated five million Iraqis and hundreds of thousands from our neighbors impoverished, detained and tortured. Saddam Hussain is the WMD in Iraq. Isnít a weapon with such capabilities worth to go for a war to (disarm it)? Saving twenty million people from that weapon, isnít that worth the effort?"
"America and the UK have offered the human race the greatest favor ever by toppling the ghoul of Iraq. All the debates and the investigations in these two countries are motivated by political ambitions and jealousy rather than the protection of the country and constitution. Bush and Blair deserve a Noble Prize for peace"
"Tony Blair made a decision for which we thank him. Heís the man who rid us of the worst dictator in history. Yes, he did a mistake when he didnít find chemical weapons but Saddam Hussain is more dangerous from those weapons for the Iraqis and Saddam had the money, the scientists and the programs and if he had remained in power he wouldíve continued producing WMDs. A world without Saddam in power is safer"
Abu Mohammed Al-Shammary-Danmark.
" The clear statement in Lord Butlerís report that emphasizes that thereís no evidence for any bad intentions for Mr. Blair in taking the decision to participate in the war, this statement confirms that his (Blairís) conscience and humanity motivated him to rid the region and the 3rd world of the ugliest dictator in the 20th century. Blairís approval of the report results and admitting that there were some mistakes uncover the courage of this young leader who reminds us of his former colleagues; Jim Callahan, Dennis Haily and Michael Foot who helped the oppressed people wherever existed. Bearing the responsibility on behalf of others despite the mistakes they made is a sign of nobility which is an important character for a good leader. Thereís no comparison between a leader who buries his people alive and a leader who offers the finest men in his nation in tribute for freedom and to defend human rights. This report reminds us of the 80s days when we were defending the hero; Nelson Mandela. while he was in prison, we were in college, collecting signatures for support. Itís the same principles Tony Blair depended on when he decided to help Iraqis get their freedom and their pride back from a butcher whoís today shaking and waiting for his destiny in a cage. We wished the report to include some words to thank Blair and his party for their role in saving human rights in Iraq."
"They shouldnít have started this war on Iraq for any reason. Life in Iraq in President Saddamís days were much better than life under occupation and Iraqis say so. Thatís why this lie about alleged Iraqi WMDs is the biggest crime against Arabs, Muslims and Iraqis"
"The least I can say about this investigation commission is that itís a play produced to save Tony Blair once again and itís very strange to see that Blair when stood in front of the parliament approved of everything in the report. And why would he not when itís the report that saved him from falling?
Strange also that he still insists that his decision was right. He just keeps being a follower for Bush. The most strange thing is how could this government take the peopleís minds so lightly. Blair is only good at holding microphones for speeches"
" If the British and American Intelligence have made a mistake and this mistake lead to the decision of the war on Saddam and liberation of Iraq from the hands of what was probably the worst tyranny ever, then what a wonderful mistake! The truth is, Blair was brave in his decision and defied all difficulties in this decision. How can anyone imagine that this was wrong? They gave us back our lost freedom and dignity"
Although this list was selected and translated by Omar, it's interesting to note that they only voices of criticism came from Syria and Palestine. The voices of Iraqis are consistent with other reports. Our Marines who have returned from Iraq tell us of how Iraqis come up to thank them for liberating them from Saddam's rule. Freedom is a wonderful thing. Omar notes, "You cannot tell a man that saving him and his family from torture, humiliation and death was a mistake and it shouldíve not been done because itís illegal. This is almost an insult to Iraqis to hear someone saying that this war was illegal. It means that our suffering for decades meant nothing and that formalities and the stupid rules of the UN (that rarely function) are more important than the lives of 25 million people. "
Posted by Deb at July 18, 2004 05:41 PM
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Wow. Thank you for posting that. I found your site today through its new listing at ORBlogs.com and I am glad for that.
The closing remark puts concisely into words what I have been thinking for a while now:
"You cannot tell a man that saving him and his family from torture, humiliation and death was a mistake and it shouldíve not been done because itís illegal. This is almost an insult to Iraqis to hear someone saying that this war was illegal. It means that our suffering for decades meant nothing and that formalities and the stupid rules of the UN (that rarely function) are more important than the lives of 25 million people."
Posted by: Greg Hughes at July 18, 2004 07:18 PM